So.
Two weeks ago Grad School BF and I had a historic fight. We'll get to that in a second, but I'd like to say a few things. One, yes, it has taken me 2 weeks to be able to talk about it (well, except to Becca, who got a drunkish hysterical phone call and slew of texts during the fight and Chelsea, who got stuck next to a drunk me the following evening at a snowed-in event) because it was That Bad. Two, I was GOING to post this tomorrow, but then I saw a really nice story and realized that Love is Hard is the message for the day BEFORE vday, while Love (all kinds!) is Worth It was the more appropriate message for the day AFTER it, and so, no post on the day. Catch up with me on Monday to hear the redeeming story after today's rambly shit show.
So let's get started!
The Fight had been building for a week, since we were at a wedding and I stupidly did that thing that girls do that goes something like this, "why do you love me, how much do you love me, but are you IN love with me" etc etc and he (even more stupidly) answered incorrectly to one of those questions.
We're like two idiots in love.
Actually, apparently, we weren't. When he said something along the lines of "you know I'm in love with you" I said "actually, no, you've never said that before" and he was like "well, I mean, I don't know" and I froze up and what was very playful and joking because a "holyshitIlivewiththisperson AND heisn'tinlovewithme AND ooooooooohmygodwe'regoingtobreakup AND thenIwillbehomeless AND IgetcoldreallyREALLYeasily."
To be fair.
There really isn't a RIGHT answer to those faux playful games. If I'm being completely honest with all of you (as I was with him two weeks ago - getting there!) he had been in touch with his ex girlfriend a few times the week prior.
Because her mom is dying.
And I am a terrible person, it's true, but it had made all my flashy warning lights go up, because why did he need to talk to her twice AND text her a few days later AND also mention that he was thinking of her one time?
BECAUSE HER MOM IS DYING.
Look, I'm not saying I'm rational. I'm saying, the big scary flashy light went on, though nothing happened but still, a little seed of scared doubt was planted, and then a few days after that he gave me an in to push the "do not push" button and I did it, and of course he didn't play the "you're the only person I've ever and will ever love(d)" and I punished him for it.
For a week.
That was a lot of weird little things, no? Seemed like that Mousetrap game from when we were kids. Remember that game? Wasn't it AWESOME? Well, when it worked I guess, which it didn't always.
I digress.
So then we had this uneasy, tiptoeing around each other week when I consulted Anna and Becca and decided that sure, of course, I was totally OK with him not being in love with me, I mean what does "in love" mean, and isn't he great? he totally is and so am I and we really are fine. Really.
Until.
Friday night before that minor snowstorm a few weeks ago that closed the city and then I mocked it (before the major snowstorms that closed the city quite rightfully. Mostly) I had dinner with a few of my girls and then had plans to go to a birthday party with Grad School BF for a girl I'm not quite friends with. But we had some time to kill, so we saw "Up in the Air."
That was a mistake.
Don't get me wrong, it was a LOVELY movie. Funny, sad, poignant, very "this is the way we live" etc etc, and (mostly) uplifting in the end. Plus, I don't know how he does it, but George Clooney is getting hotter by the MINUTE.
However.
The scared voice inside of me that was saying, "We're fine. We're fine. We're fine," in an increasingly shrill and desperate tone took hold of that movie and ran around me doing a little dance saying, "you are not fine! Even if you think you are, even if you're living in a nice looking apartment in Chicago with two cute kids, your WIFE is just CHEATING on you with a GEORGE CLOONEY LOOK ALIKE who you will never, ever compare to in looks. AND sexually."
The voice also waved a flag. It was neon. And scary.
And maybe that would have been fine. If the birthday party wasn't JUST for a girl I don't really know, but also who happens to be the best friend of a DIFFERENT girl who I was briefly convinced in October of last year luuuuuuuuved Grad School BF.
Who are we kidding - I still think that.
Why? I don't know! Because... she's pretty. And he is too. And because they're the same age. And because she plays soccer, and so does he. And I LIKE soccer, but I haven't played since my fourth year in college which btw was just intramurals, not like legit playing, and now my soccer involvement extends to my formerly muscular but now fat thighs sitting on a couch or bar stool guzzling beer, chomping on wings and shouting obscenities at the television.
Who WOULDN'T love me?!
If, once again, I'm completely honest with you I really don't have any particular reason I think she likes him, and even if she did, I really DO trust Grad School BF as much as I trust any man who isn't my dad. More so, actually. WAY more so.
But when am I honest? Rational? NEVER.
So back to the story, we were headed to this party, me on the verge (and sometime falling off) of tears from this very moving movie, and also, from the internal battle that was burning up between my angelic demons and my demonic demons that were freaking out about something I kind of pushed Grad School BF into saying. And we get to the party, and this chick is there, and she's all "hiiii BF" and ignoring me and because he's nice (or because he was sick of me kind of crying on the metro ride over from the movie theatre) he did not have interest in talking to me either so I was left drinking a beer with some guy I barely know while most of the party went to the dance floor.
Including BF, and this girl.
After a few beers and a few more than that minutes of faking cheeriness, I was over this party. I wanted to go home, I wanted to go to bed, and I REALLY wanted to cry. So I went to the dance floor to find BF and I saw him.
Dancing with that girl.
Last time to be honest - when I angrily texted him four minutes later, I implied that he was grinding up against her, when really, it was more the kind of harmless (ish) dancing that you do at a wedding before taking advantage of the open bar. You know. A foot apart, hands waving awkwardly, smiling and singing. But if I'm ALSO honest, I don't care. I certainly didn't then, and I don't really now - he knew I didn't trust her, he knew how I felt, and you don't go dancing with people who your girlfriend thinks likes you.
I think I got that out correctly.
Grad School BF, apparently, disagrees, and so there he was. I was kind of in shock - my entire body got very, very cold, I spun on my heel and in a haze gathered my coat, texted Becca, and told the guy I had been talking to that he could tell BF I had left (I also texted him, in my defense). I walked out of the bar, said goodbye to the birthday girl, and burst into tears a block away. REAL tears. The kind that I don't really cry, because it makes you feel like you've lost control and if there's anything I really hate, it's losing control.
At this point BF texted and asked what had happened.
Then I sent the abovementioned "grinding" text and he texted back saying do not get on the metro, I will be right there (because he knew I wouldn't have cab fare, because I never carry cash) and so I looked at the clock - 5 minutes until a train came. I had to give him that much anyway, so I might as well.
He showed up in 4 mins, 30 secs.
We got on the metro, me hysterically whuffing into his coat, him the very image of shock and confusion, as we went the one stop to our house. We went upstairs in silence (well, sniffles from me) and then we sat down on the couch.
And had it out.
At first it was just me, shouting at him, but as the accusations grew his face got stonier and stonier until he started shouting back. How could he DO this to me, it was so EMBARRASSING, but WHAT was so embarrassing, he hadn't DONE anything, HOW COULD HE SAY THAT? HE WAS ALL UP ON THAT GIRL! what the FUCK AM I TALKING ABOUT, he wasn't even TOUCHING her.
After a while.
I got upset in earnest, and made really terrible metaphors like, "I've gone all in here and you're not even playing" while he was like "I love you, why don't you trust in that" and we were both talking AT each other, not TO each other.
And then.
We started listening to each other, which was a lot harder because it made me give up my righteous indignation, and he had to listen to some ugly truths about how, after 18 months as besties, 9 months of dating and 6 months of living together, I still was super insecure. About how his talking to his ex is fine, and also, I don't want to be the type of girlfriend who has to approve things, but it makes me uncomfortable. About how dancing with girls I'm positive like him, regardless of how crazy I'm being, is NOT ok, and yet I STILL don't want to be the type of girlfriend who has to approve things.
Sigh.
At this point is was like, 4am, and we decided to call a truce. For a day we made an effort at being overly nice to each other, and then on Sunday we revisited with cooler heads. At this point he was like, look, I don't see a problem dancing with chicks because I love YOU and nothing would ever EVER happen, and by the way, you are just CRAZILY emotional, and not internally, externally, so all your feelings are right out there, exhibited, so the reason you think you love me more is because you're OUT there with it, and yes, I am more reserved, but also you are way LESS reserved than most people.
At this point I said weepily, "but you're not in lo-huh-huh-hove with meeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee."
And while this is not the point of this particular post (do all my posts have a point? Do ANY?), let me take this small sidenote to say: make sure you define your terms. When you're in academia, (or at least when I was), all your professors are like "define your terms! Define your terms!" as though that is the only thing that matters (while I liked to think things like argument and persuasion counted for something). But those professors were onto something. Don't use (or freak out over) terms like "in love" if the meaning hasn't been clearly defined. Apparently, Grad School BF thinks that "in love" is the moment when you realize you want to get married.
I, um, do not.
And while again, that's not the point, it's funny how something so dumb could have erupted into something so VERY large. Just think if I had only paid a little more attention in my core classes almost 10 (ugh) years ago, maybe I wouldn't have had to hastily beat a bar because I was about to get all sorts of messy. And maybe I would have! Though it would probably have started over something else equally distressing. Don't get me wrong - we're fine.
For real this time.
But that weekend was rough. And the week after it wasn't so hot, especially as I worried about what we were going to do being snowed in together and only together for 3 days (haha. Three. Ha). But a year ago, my life wasn't SUPER duper awesome, but it was my own. My ups were my ups, and my downs were... drownable in a big glass of wine. Now, it's SUPER DUPER AWESOME... when it's not heart-wrenchingly tragic. Life is complicated. Love is even more so. Put them together, and love ain't just not easy - it's pretty fucking hard.